Crafting the Quantum
Arnold Sommerfeld (1868–1951) was among the most significant contributors to the birth of modern theoretical physics. At the University of Munich, beginning in 1906, he trained two generations of theoretical physicists. Eight of his students (among them Werner Heisenberg, Wolfgang Pauli, and Hans Bethe) went on to receive Nobel Prizes. In Crafting the Quantum, Suman Seth offers the first English-language book-length study of Sommerfeld's work, presenting an intellectual and cultural history of theoretical physics in Germany viewed through the lens of Sommerfeld's research and pedagogy.
Seth examines the practical origins of much of the research undertaken by Sommerfeld at the university, some of which addressed problems carried over from his years of teaching at an engineering school. Some of the research done by Sommerfeld and his students found applications during World War I to such problems as the stability of aircraft wings and the functioning and directional operation of antennas. Seth describes in detail Sommerfeld’s pedagogical practice, including his characteristic amalgamation of research and teaching. He relates the history of the “older” quantum theory and Sommerfeld’s engagement with the work of Max Planck and Niels Bohr and compares Sommerfeld’s “physics of problems” to Planck’s and Bohr’s more abstract “physics of principles.” To illuminate the nature of Sommerfeld’s work, Seth offers detailed descriptions of the contrasting work of other theorists. Seth’s innovative account challenges idealist depictions of the nature of theoretical work in physics, describing not only modes of practice but also the multiple areas of intellectual, political, and social life from which science draws resources and to which it contributes.
Transformations: Studies in the History of Science and Technology series
About the Author
Suman Seth is Assistant Professor in the Department of Science and Technology Studies at Cornell University.
"This is a very impressive book, containing numerous new and innovative ideas and interpretations of the life and work of Arnold Sommerfeld and the school he led. A major contribution and a stirring history of some of the key players in quantum theory."
Andrew Warwick, Professor of History of Science, Imperial College, London
"Suman Seth has produced a fascinating study of intellectual styles and local scientific traditions. By a probing analysis of the work on the early quantum theory Seth is able to distinguish in an illuminating way between what he calls the physics of principles (developed by Planck) and the physics of problems (developed by Sommerfeld). This is not a superficial distinction between preferred methods of presentation but, as Seth demonstrates, one that goes to the technical heart of their work. This is not just a book that will be of interest to experts in the history of quantum theory. It calls into question the application of ideas such as that of a 'revolution' in physics and challenges the reader to see and explain analogous patterns elsewhere in science and engineering."
David Bloor, Emeritus Professor in the Sociology of Science, University of Edinburgh
"Suman Seth presents a refreshingly original interpretation of the work of Sommerfeld and his school that is sure to stimulate a much-needed re-evaluation of the route to quantum mechanics."
David C. Cassidy, Department of Chemistry, Hofstra University, author of Beyond Uncertainty: Heisenberg, Quantum Physics, and the Bomb