Logic and God in Lacan
A philosophical examination of the treatment of logic and God in Lacan's later psychoanalytic theory.
In The Not-Two, Lorenzo Chiesa examines the treatment of logic and God in Lacan's later work. Chiesa draws for the most part from Lacan's Seminars of the early 1970s, as they revolve around the axiom “There is no sexual relationship.” Chiesa provides both a close reading of Lacan's effort to formalize sexual difference as incompleteness and an assessment of its broader implications for philosophical realism and materialism.
Chiesa argues that “There is no sexual relationship” is for Lacan empirically and historically circumscribed by psychoanalysis, yet self-evident in our everyday lives. Lacan believed that we have sex because we love, and that love is a desire to be One in face of the absence of the sexual relationship. Love presupposes a real “not-two.” The not-two condenses the idea that our love and sex lives are dictated by the impossibility of fusing man's contradictory being with the heteros of woman as a fundamentally uncountable Other. Sexual liaisons are sustained by a transcendental logic, the so-called phallic function that attempts to overcome this impossibility.
Chiesa also focuses on Lacan's critical dialogue with modern science and formal logic, as well as his dismantling of sexuality as considered by mainstream biological discourse. Developing a new logic of sexuation based on incompleteness requires the relinquishing of any alleged logos of life and any teleological evolution.
For Lacan, the truth of incompleteness as approached psychoanalytically through sexuality would allow us to go further in debunking traditional onto-theology and replace it with a “para-ontology” yet to be developed. Given the truth of incompleteness, Chiesa asks, can we think such a truth in itself without turning incompleteness into another truth about truth, that is, into yet another figure of God as absolute being?
Lorenzo Chiesa's The Not-Two admirably makes creative landmark contributions to both Lacanian studies and contemporary metaphysics. On the basis of an unpacking of Lacan's treatments of sexual difference from the early 1970s unprecedented in its attentiveness and elegance, Chiesa builds toward a compelling novel ontology motivated by the fundamental question: What must being or nature be so as to eventuate in the distinctively dysfunctional entities that are the sexed human subjects of psychoanalysis?
Adrian Johnston, Professor, Department of Philosophy, University of New Mexico at Albuquerque
Love is a cosmic principle; conflict and love have been taken to govern the world; love has been known to seek for the One. In The Not-Two Chiesa addresses questions of sexual love, as he takes up themes from Lacan's work in this illuminating study of what it is that counts between women and men.
Bernard Burgoyne, psychoanalyst; Emeritus Professor of Psychoanalysis, Middlesex University