All psychologists concerned with reasoning will find that Stich's reflections on it deepen their understanding of the topic.
Richard E. Nisbett, Contemporary Psychology
A wonderful book. It provides a total reworking of philosophical epistemology, a 'deconstruction,' as they say. Stich offers an exciting philosophical challenge to the whole field, and a persuasive case for a real pragmatism. The book is clear, straightforward and enjoyable to read, with an engaging human voice. It provides students with a model of how to do philosophy.
Gilbert Harman, Princeton University
In Stich's development of his new position, pragmatist epistemology has at last achieved a reasoned advocacy that combines lucidity with sophistication
L. Jonathan Cohen, Oxford University
It is a book which has many of the merits prized by philosophers of the analytic school: lucidity, terseness, wealth of argument, respect for the findings of empirical science, and - dare one say it - all the appearances of an honest commitment to the pursuit Of truth.
E. J. Lowe, Philosophical Quarterly