A Lunch BIT from The Consciousness Paradox by Rocco Gennaro
To answer your first question: No, the HOT Thesis has nothing do with the (formerly?) popular website Hot or Not. It refers instead to Rocco Gennaro’s “higher-order thought” theory of consciousness. The “Consciousness Paradox” in his book’s title refers to a number of competing theories of consciousness, all of which seem plausible even though some are in obvious tension, if not contradiction, with others. One of them is the HOT Thesis: what makes a mental state conscious is that a suitable higher-order thought is directed at that mental state. To simplify somewhat, consciousness consists in a mental state that necessarily involves awareness of that mental state. In In Defense of the HOT Thesis: A BIT of The Consciousness Paradox, Gennaro defends the veracity of this thesis – later chapters argue that other theories of consciousness are, in fact, consistent with it.
It’s philosophy of mind of a high order, for certain. But then, consciousness is a hard problem to solve. In fact, a favorite review of Gennaro’s book (from the Australasian Journal of Philosophy) did the welcome job of stepping back and putting the book into some intellectual context vis a vis those efforts:
“Rocco Gennaro’s book gives us one of the best recent defences of the ‘higher-order’ approach to explaining phenomenal consciousness. This approach, championed in different forms by David Armstrong, David Rosenthal, and William Lycan, holds that a mental state is conscious when one is appropriately aware of being in that state. Gennaro offers a single state or ‘self-representational’ version, where the awareness and its target are part of a single complex mental state, a state tracking both the world and that very state itself…The Consciousness Paradox is part of a new wave of philosophical focus on the higher-order view. The book is an excellent introduction to the overall approach, as well as an intriguing in-depth defence of Gennaro’s particular variation…Gennaro may not have fully dispelled the air of paradox, but he has made clear that the approach is a viable and important contender in the effort to crack the hard problem of consciousness.”
Or, if you prefer to use an RSS reader, you can subscribe to the Blog RSS feed.RSS
Blogs We Like
Books, news, and ideas from MIT Press
The MIT PressLog is the official blog of MIT Press. Founded in 2005, the Log chronicles news about MIT Press authors and books. The MIT PressLog also serves as forum for our authors to discuss issues related to their books and scholarship. Views expressed by guest contributors to the blog do not necessarily represent those of MIT Press.