Skip navigation
Hardcover | Out of Print | 240 pp. | 7 x 9 in | 23 b&w photos, 13 b&w illus., 21 maps, 21 graphs | January 2010 | ISBN: 9780262195935
Paperback | $17.95 Trade | £14.95 | 240 pp. | 7 x 9 in | 23 b&w photos, 13 b&w illus., 21 maps, 21 graphs | August 2014 | ISBN: 9780262526852
eBook | $12.95 Trade | January 2010 | ISBN: 9780262288286
Mouseover for Online Attention Data

Look Inside

Why America Is Not a New Rome


America’s post–Cold War strategic dominance and its pre-recession affluence inspired pundits to make celebratory comparisons to ancient Rome at its most powerful. Now, with America no longer perceived as invulnerable, engaged in protracted fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan, and suffering the worst economic downturn since the Great Depression, comparisons are to the bloated, decadent, ineffectual later Empire. In Why America Is Not a New Rome, Vaclav Smil looks at these comparisons in detail, going deeper than the facile analogy-making of talk shows and glossy magazine articles. He finds profound differences.

Smil, a scientist and a lifelong student of Roman history, focuses on several fundamental concerns: the very meaning of empire; the actual extent and nature of Roman and American power; the role of knowledge and innovation; and demographic and economic basics--population dynamics, illness, death, wealth, and misery. America is not a latter-day Rome, Smil finds, and we need to understand this in order to look ahead without the burden of counterproductive analogies. Superficial similarities do not imply long-term political, demographic, or economic outcomes identical to Rome’s.

About the Author

Vaclav Smil is Distinguished Professor Emeritus at the University of Manitoba. He is the author of forty books, including Power Density: A Key to Understanding Energy Sources and Uses and Made in the USA: The Rise and Retreat of American Manufacturing, both published by the MIT Press. In 2010 he was named by Foreign Policy as one of the Top 100 Global Thinkers. In 2013 Bill Gates wrote on his website that “there is no author whose books I look forward to more than Vaclav Smil.”


“[T]his book is both a polemic and a work of scholarship.”—Daniel Headrick, Technology and Culture
“Smil (Univ. of Manitoba, Canada) has written an entertaining response to authors who have compared the US to the Roman Empire...”—S. Prisco III, CHOICE


“Repetition by pundits and literary commentators in the mass media has entrenched in people’s minds the notion that America is a new Rome. Smil’s book, tightly argued and rigorously documented, is a concise and persuasive scientific demolition of the Rome-America parallel, totally deflating the usefulness of the analogy as a tool of historical analysis. Why America is Not a New Rome is a much-needed corrective.”
Paul Demeny, Distinguished Scholar, Population Council, New York